Russian tanks

© AP
Russian tanks in drills at the Kadamovskiy firing range in the Rostov region in southern Russian federation
Jan. 12, 2022

In a recent press conference held on the occasion of a visit to Moscow by Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, Russian President Vladimir Putin spoke about connected NATO expansion, and the potential consequences if Ukraine was to join the trans-Atlantic alliance. He said:

"Their [NATO's] main task is to incorporate the development of Russia. Ukraine is just a tool to achieve this goal. They could describe us into some kind of armed conflict and force their allies in Europe to impose the very tough sanctions that are being talked near in the Usa today. Or they could draw Ukraine into NATO, set up strike weapons systems there and encourage some people to resolve the issue of Donbass or Crimea past strength, and still draw u.s.a. into an armed conflict."

Putin continued:

"Allow usa imagine that Ukraine is a NATO member and is blimp with weapons and there are state-of-the-art missile systems just like in Poland and Romania. Who will stop it from unleashing operations in Crimea, let alone Donbass? Let us imagine that Ukraine is a NATO member and ventures such a gainsay operation. Practise we have to fight with the NATO bloc? Has anyone idea anything most information technology? It seems not."

But these words were dismissed by White House spokesperson Jen Psaki, who likened them to a fox "screaming from the elevation of the hen house that he's scared of the chickens," calculation that whatever Russian expression of fright over Ukraine "should not be reported as a argument of fact."

Psaki's comments, however, are divorced from the reality of the situation. The master goal of the government of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is what he terms the " de-occupation" of Crimea. While this goal has, in the past, been couched in terms of diplomacy - "[t]he synergy of our efforts must force Russia to negotiate the render of our peninsula," Zelensky told the Crimea Platform, a Ukrainian forum focused on regaining control over Crimea - the reality is his strategy for return is a purely military i, in which Russia has been identified equally a "military machine antagonist", and the accomplishment of which can merely be achieved through NATO membership.

How Zelensky plans on accomplishing this goal using military means has not been spelled out. As an ostensibly defensive alliance, the odds are that NATO would not initiate any offensive armed services action to forcibly seize the Crimean Peninsula from Russia. Indeed, the terms of Ukraine's membership, if granted, would demand to include some language regarding the limits of NATO's Article v - which relates to commonage defense force - when addressing the Crimea situation, or else a state of state of war would de facto exist upon Ukrainian accession.

The about likely scenario would involve Ukraine being apace brought under the 'umbrella' of NATO protection, with 'battlegroups' like those deployed into eastern Europe beingness formed on Ukrainian soil as a 'trip-wire' strength, and mod air defenses combined with forward-deployed NATO aircraft put in place to secure Ukrainian airspace.

Once this umbrella has been established, Ukraine would feel emboldened to begin a hybrid conflict confronting what it terms the Russian occupation of Crimea, employing unconventional warfare capability it has acquired since 2015 at the hands of the CIA to initiate an insurgency designed specifically to "kill Russians."

The thought that Russia would sit idly by while a guerilla war in Crimea was existence implemented from Ukraine is ludicrous; if confronted with such a scenario, Russia would more than likely use its own anarchistic capabilities in retaliation. Ukraine, of form, would weep foul, and NATO would be confronted with its mandatory obligation for collective defence force under Article five. In short, NATO would be at war with Russia.

This is non idle speculation. When explaining his recent decision to deploy some 3,000 US troops to Europe in response to the ongoing Ukrainian crunch, The states President Joe Biden declared:

"Every bit long equally he'due south [Putin] acting aggressively, we are going to make certain we reassure our NATO allies in Eastern Europe that we're at that place and Article 5 is a sacred obligation."

Biden's comments echo those made during his initial visit to NATO Headquarters, on June fifteen terminal year. At that fourth dimension, Biden sat downwardly with NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg and emphasized America'southward commitment to Article 5 of the NATO charter. Biden said:

"Article 5 we take as a sacred obligation. I want NATO to know America is at that place."

Biden'due south view of NATO and Ukraine is drawn from his experience equally vice president under Barack Obama. In 2015, then-Deputy Secretary of Defense Bob Work told reporters:

"As President Obama has said, Ukraine should ... exist able to choose its own future. And we pass up any talk of a sphere of influence. And speaking in Estonia this past September, the president made it clear that our commitment to our NATO allies in the face of Russian aggression is unwavering. As he said it, in this brotherhood there are no erstwhile members and in that location are no new members. There are no junior partners and there are no senior partners. There are just allies, pure and uncomplicated. And we will defend the territorial integrity of every single ally."

But what would this defense force entail? As someone who once trained to fight the Soviet Army, I tin can attest that a war with Russia would exist unlike anything the US war machine has experienced - ever. The US armed forces is neither organized, trained, nor equipped to fight its Russian counterparts. Nor does it possess doctrine capable of supporting large-calibration combined arms conflict. If the Us was to be drawn into a conventional ground war with Russia, it would observe itself facing defeat on a calibration unprecedented in American military history. In brusque, it would be a rout.

Don't take my word for information technology. In 2016, then-Lieutenant General H.R. McMaster, when speaking nigh the results of a study - the Russian federation New Generation Warfare - he had initiated in 2015 to examine lessons learned from the fighting in eastern Ukraine, told an audience at the Eye for Strategic and International Studies in Washington that the Russians take superior artillery firepower, ameliorate combat vehicles, and have learned sophisticated apply of unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) for tactical event.

"Should Us forces discover themselves in a land state of war with Russia, they would be in for a rude, cold enkindling."

In short, they would go their asses kicked.

America's 20-year Centre Eastern misadventure in Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria produced a armed services that was no longer capable of defeating a peer-level opponent on the battleground. This reality was highlighted in a report conducted by the US Army'due south 173rd Airborne Brigade, the fundamental American component of NATO's Rapid Deployment Forcefulness, in 2017. The study found that U.s.a. armed forces forces in Europe were underequipped, undermanned, and inadequately organized to face armed forces aggression from Russia. The lack of viable air defense and electronic warfare capability, when combined with an over-reliance on satellite communications and GPS navigation systems, would effect in the piecemeal destruction of the United states Army in rapid order should they face off confronting a Russian military that was organized, trained, and equipped to specifically defeat a The states/NATO threat.

The issue isn't but qualitative, but too quantitative - even if the US military could stand toe-to-toe with a Russian adversary (which information technology can't), it merely lacks the size to survive in whatever sustained battle or campaign. The depression-intensity conflict that the US military machine waged in Iraq and Afghanistan has created an organizational ethos built around the idea that every American life is precious, and that all efforts volition exist made to evacuate the wounded so that they tin receive life-saving medical attention in equally short a timeframe as possible. This concept may accept been viable where the U.s. was in control of the environment in which fights were conducted. It is, however, pure fiction in big-scale combined artillery warfare. At that place won't be medical evacuation helicopters flying to the rescue - even if they launched, they would exist shot down. There won't be field ambulances - even if they arrived on the scene, they would be destroyed in brusque order. In that location won't be field hospitals - even if they were established, they would be captured by Russian mobile forces.

What there will be is death and destruction, and lots of it. Ane of the events which triggered McMaster's report of Russian warfare was the destruction of a Ukrainian combined arms brigade past Russian artillery in early 2015. This, of course, would be the fate of whatsoever similar US combat germination. The superiority Russian federation enjoys in artillery fires is overwhelming, both in terms of the numbers of artillery systems fielded and the lethality of the munitions employed.

While the US Air Force may be able to mount a fight in the airspace higher up any battlefield, at that place will be zilch like the total air supremacy enjoyed by the American armed services in its operations in Republic of iraq and Afghanistan. The airspace will be contested past a very capable Russian air strength, and Russian ground troops volition be operating under an air defense umbrella the likes of which neither the US nor NATO has ever faced. There will be no close air support cavalry coming to the rescue of beleaguered American troops. The forces on the ground will be on their own.

This feeling of isolation volition exist furthered by the reality that, because of Russia'due south overwhelming superiority in electronic warfare adequacy , the U.s.a. forces on the ground will be deaf, dumb, and bullheaded to what is happening around them, unable to communicate, receive intelligence, and even operate as radios, electronic systems, and weapons stop to part.

Any state of war with Russia would find American forces slaughtered in large numbers. Back in the 1980s, we routinely trained to accept losses of thirty-forty percent and continue the fight, considering that was the reality of modern combat against a Soviet threat. Dorsum then, we were able to effectively match the Soviets in terms of strength size, structure, and capability - in short, we could give as good, or better, than we got.

That wouldn't be the case in any European war against Russian federation. The The states volition lose most of its forces before they are able to close with whatever Russian adversary, due to deep artillery fires. Even when they shut with the enemy, the advantage the U.s.a. enjoyed against Iraqi and Taliban insurgents and ISIS terrorists is a affair of the past. Our tactics are no longer upwards to par - when in that location is close gainsay, it will be extraordinarily fierce, and the Usa will, more times than not, come out on the losing side.

Merely even if the Usa manages to win the odd tactical engagement confronting peer-level infantry, it simply has no counter to the overwhelming number of tanks and armored fighting vehicles Russian federation will bring to bear. Even if the anti-tank weapons in the possession of US ground troops were effective against modern Russian tanks (and experience suggests they are probably not), American troops will merely exist overwhelmed past the mass of combat strength the Russians will confront them with.

In the 1980s, I had the opportunity to participate in a Soviet-manner attack carried out past specially trained United states Ground forces troops - the 'OPFOR' - at the National Training Center in Fort Irwin, California, where ii Soviet-style Mechanized Infantry Regiments squared off against a US Army Mechanized Brigade. The fight began at around two in the morning. By five:30am information technology was over, with the United states of america Brigade destroyed, and the Soviets having seized their objectives. There'southward something about 170 armored vehicles begetting down on your position that makes defeat all but inevitable.

This is what a state of war with Russia would look like. It would not be express to Ukraine, merely extend to battlefields in the Baltic states, Poland, Romania, and elsewhere. Information technology would involve Russian strikes against NATO airfields, depots, and ports throughout the depth of Europe.

This is what will happen if the U.s. and NATO seek to attach the "sacred obligation" of Commodity 5 of the NATO Charter to Ukraine. It is, in brusk, a suicide pact.

Near the Writer:
Scott Ritter is a sometime The states Marine Corps intelligence officer and author of 'SCORPION KING: America's Suicidal Cover of Nuclear Weapons from FDR to Trump.' He served in the Soviet Union equally an inspector implementing the INF Treaty, in General Schwarzkopf's staff during the Gulf War, and from 1991-1998 equally a United nations weapons inspector. Follow him on Twitter @RealScottRitter